ReadItSwapIt
ReadItSwapIt Book Logo
ReadItSwapIt Forums Sign in | Forum FAQ

Shortcuts

White Stone Day by John MacLachlan Gray

Last post 07-23-2012 15:47 by alisondavina. 4 replies.
Page 1 of 1 (5 items)
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 07-22-2012 21:04 Post ID: 1,008,312 

    White Stone Day by John MacLachlan Gray

    (I read this last year & was convinced I had already posted my review, but as I definitely can't locate it, am adding now, instead!) 

    SYNOPSIS: In peaceful, idyllic Oxford, a young reverend finds amusement in entertaining his colleague's daughters with riddles, stories and photography. In grimy, Victorian London, a literally down at heel journalist finds himself investigating a séance only to receive an unexpected message from his deceased brother, followed by finding himself falsely imprisoned for a murder he did not commit. These disparate & seemingly unconnected storylines intertwine into a compelling period mystery.

    THOUGHTS: Gray’s fictionalised portrait of Lewis Carroll is unmistakable, and I think remarkably well done, even down to the poetry-after-the-style-of. I was relieved that despite a plot largely based around child pornography/photography, Gray did not succumb to making Carroll/Boltbyn the villain of the piece, and in fact painted a very sympathetic picture, despite the scandal that has historically dogged Carroll’s friendship with the young Alice Liddell.

    But this mystery novel is far more than an homage to/veiled biography of Carroll. The chapters spliced between the Oxford ‘idyll’ kept me equally entertained, with wonderful descriptions of Whitty's life in London told lightly, and with a deadpan, self-deprecating wit. This was my second reading of ‘White Stone Day’ and I enjoyed it even more than first time around. Gray manages to tell a distasteful tale without leaving a sour taste in the mouth, and in fact leaving the reader anxiously awaiting a second helping.

    Neverendings / TangleCrafts / Enchanted Times

    Currently reading: Petite Mort by Beatrice Hitchman



  • 07-22-2012 22:10 Post ID: 1,008,343  In reply to

    • wyres
    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-23-2008
    • Here and there!
    • Posts 17,867

    Re: White Stone Day by John MacLachlan Gray

    This sounds very interesting indeed, thanks for the review.

    Have you ever read the books by The Looking Glass Wars Trilogy by Frank Beddor they are based on Alice in Wonderland too.  It was one of the books in the 2010/11 Book Circles.

    Superman or Christian Gray or in person Mr Cavill.
  • 07-23-2012 6:29 Post ID: 1,008,389  In reply to

    Re: White Stone Day by John MacLachlan Gray

    wyres:

    Have you ever read the books by The Looking Glass Wars Trilogy by Frank Beddor they are based on Alice in Wonderland too.

    I haven't - once started the first one years ago but didn't see it through.  I do keep meaning to try again one day, though...    I've read several other fictionalised versions of Lewis carroll & Alice Liddell, though, including Still She Haunts Me by Katie Roiphe and After Such Kindness by Gaynor Arnold (this one is a spoiler thread).  I also have Alice I have Been by Melanie Benjamin on my wishlist - one day I'll finally splash out and buy it...

     

    Neverendings / TangleCrafts / Enchanted Times

    Currently reading: Petite Mort by Beatrice Hitchman



  • 07-23-2012 12:14 Post ID: 1,008,442  In reply to

    Re: White Stone Day by John MacLachlan Gray

    Have you read Automated Alice by Jeff Noon?  I have to say I didn't like it, wasn't really my cup of tea. I did read the first in the Looking Glass Wars series on Bernie's recommendation though and I enjoyed that one.

  • 07-23-2012 15:47 Post ID: 1,008,475  In reply to

    Re: White Stone Day by John MacLachlan Gray

    I've had White Stone Day on my TBR for a long time and picked it up and put it down several times. Having read this review, I'm itching to pick it up again.

    Paw prints on my heart.
Page 1 of 1 (5 items)