ReadItSwapIt
ReadItSwapIt Book Logo
ReadItSwapIt Forums Sign in | Forum FAQ

Shortcuts

Guernica by Dave Boling

Last post 02-01-2010 12:38 by dingsy. 11 replies.
Page 1 of 1 (12 items)
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 07-04-2009 15:34 Post ID: 573,376 

    Guernica by Dave Boling

    Synopsis: In 1935, Miguel Navarro finds himself in conflict with the Spanish Civil Guard and flees the Basque fishing village of Lekeitio to make a new start in Guernica, the centre of Basque culture and tradition.  Once there, he finds more than just a new life - he finds someone to live for.  Miren Ansotegui is the charismatic and graceful dancer he meets and the two discover a love they believe nothing can destroy. 

    Rich in the history of the region, the Red Baron, the Luftwaffe and even Picasso make an appearance in Guernica, as the fate of the Ansotegui and Navarro families are traced through the early decades of the twentieth century.

    This is a book of two halves really and I can see why it has been compared to Captain Corelli's Mandolin, with its mixture of quirky local characters and the horrors of warfare (but don't panic those of you who struggled with Corelli, this is a much easier read).

    The first half is quite whimsical and humorous, following the story of the Ansotegui brothers as they grow up on a farm in the Basque country and afterwards as they set off on their chosen paths as farmer, fisherman and priest.  Justo Ansotegui's daughter marries Miguel Navarro and they live a seemingly idyllic life, with only hints and rumours of the events taking place elsewhere in Spain. 

    (Incidentally, quite a lot of characters from various families are introduced in the first few chapters, mostly with Spanish names beginning with J, M or A, and it can get a bit confusing at times, but by about a third of the way in I'd got a handle on who was who.)

    The background to this is the complex politics of the Spanish Civil War, with Franco declaring war on the Basque people for their perceived splitting of the Spanish nation and for blocking his attempts to capture Bilbao.  Again, don't panic - this isn't a book about politicians, it's about the people who have to live with their catastrophic decisions.

    The bombing of Guernica by Franco's German allies, and the death and devastation that ensue, are horrifically portrayed over 15 pages in the middle of the book.  Dave Boling says in his author's note that the actual death toll at Guernica is disputed, but the reason the bombing had such resonance is that it was an attack on a civilian population.  As one of the heroes of the book, Father Xabier Ansotegui says, "When you see burned children laying in the street, charred, melted, you don't count them.  When you see a group of boys fused into a blackened mass, you don't take an inventory.  How many died?  How many?  Death was infinite."

    Father Ansotegui is based on a real priest who was a close advisor to the Basque president and witnessed the bombing.  Other real life figures make cameo appearances in the book, including Picasso who was living in Paris at the time but read about the atrocity in the newspapers and was compelled to paint his famous mural.

    This is Dave Boling's first novel and he was inspired to write it by his wife's Basque family who told him about the bombing.  I thoroughly enjoyed it and found it an informative and ultimately uplifting read.

    Currently reading: Mr Rosenblum's List - Natasha Solomons
  • 07-04-2009 17:20 Post ID: 573,419  In reply to

    • jobar
    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-04-2007
    • In the land of pies and piers....
    • Posts 13,762

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

     Just started this and am getting used to all the Spanish names ...I'm enjoying it so far !!

  • 07-04-2009 20:55 Post ID: 573,508  In reply to

    • sarita
    • Top 75 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-04-2007
    • Gerpinnes, Belgium
    • Posts 3,245

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

    Will read this in the reading group later this year

    Sarita

    Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened.

    MySwaps
  • 07-04-2009 23:11 Post ID: 573,551  In reply to

    • annecater
    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-04-2007
    • Land of Red Arrows & Sausages
    • Posts 23,504

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

    The publisher sent me a proof copy of this one last year but it never really appealled to me and I sent it on to MaryAnne in Dubai.  I didnt like Captain Correlli either!








  • 07-06-2009 10:25 Post ID: 573,990  In reply to

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

     I read the proof copy for Amazon Vine; a good book, if a little family saga-ish at times:

     

    The list of atrocities that dot the 20th Century is a long one and not all of them are contained within the years of World Wars 1 and 2.  One atrocity that occurred in 1937 was the bombing of Basque town Guernica as a way for the German's to test their modern warfare techniques and Franco to stamp his authority on the famously stubborn Basque people.  `Guernica' follows a Basque family over three generations in the lead up, during and after the bombing that left many dead and many more injured.

    For such heavy subject matter it is surprising to see how light `Guernica' is.  Dave Boling seems to have written more of a family saga than a meaningful political book.  The first 200 pages or so are a mere build up to the inevitable.  I found the family dynamic in the book a little cute to be realistic and that the heart strings were being too obviously pulled by Boling as obvious plotlines appeared.  However, giving the reader a rich understanding of the victims works as the 50 pages that surround the actual bombing are more powerful because you feel you know the victims.

    I think that a reader's enjoyment of `Guernica' will vary depending on their approach to the book.  I think that the subject matter dictates that they should expect a dark and harrowing book that looks at the atrocities of conflict. This is far from the case and these people will be disappointed.  However, if you read the book expecting a family drama that contains many highs, but some lows, then you will enjoy this book.  Personally, I liked the book a lot as a slightly patronising, but good natured, look at the Basque way of life between the wars.

    I am currently reading:The Ghost by Robert Harris (There's a ghost in my house, I can't hide!)
  • 07-06-2009 10:34 Post ID: 573,997  In reply to

    • ferney
    • Top 500 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-07-2009
    • in other worlds through bookshaped holes
    • Posts 200

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

    Although this seems a very popular choice at the moment I can't say that I fancied it at all to be honest. Hmm

    Still horses for courses and all that.

     

     

     

    Reading ~ Wolfsangel by M. D. Lachlan
  • 07-06-2009 11:53 Post ID: 574,036  In reply to

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

     I've just put this down as my first choice for my free book from Newbooks Magazine so I look forward to reading it eventually.

    Wendy

    My Wishlist
    My Swaps
    Currently reading: The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society by Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows
  • 07-06-2009 19:43 Post ID: 574,241  In reply to

    • jobar
    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-04-2007
    • In the land of pies and piers....
    • Posts 13,762

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

     I've really enjoyed this book. At times quite uplifting with some earthy humour and at other times quite heart rending. My previous knowlege of Guernica was limited to studying Picasso's famous painting for my art A'level, now I can appreciate the imagery and the horror.

    Well worth a read.

  • 07-06-2009 22:11 Post ID: 574,301  In reply to

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

    Thanks for the review! Looking forward to reading this, is on my TBR pile. Liked reading 'Winter in Madrid' and 'The Return' and have become interested in finding out more about the Spanish Civil War from reading these novels, as I knew little about it previously.

  • 08-11-2009 22:04 Post ID: 591,012  In reply to

    • kahlan
    • Top 50 Contributor
    • Joined on 09-09-2007
    • Buckinghamshire
    • Posts 4,558

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

    Excellent review Denise. I finished this book last week and agree whole-heartedly with everything you have said. Before starting it, I was a little worried that it might be quite a heavy read but it wasn't at all.

    Kahlan My swaps
    Had an accident?
    Currently Reading: And Another Thing (Jeremy Clarkson) and Poison Study (Maria V Snyder)
  • 12-20-2009 16:03 Post ID: 654,689  In reply to

    • sarita
    • Top 75 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-04-2007
    • Gerpinnes, Belgium
    • Posts 3,245

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

    I just finished this and really loved it. I expected all sorts of things, from total horror (there is some) to total indifference when I started the first part.

    It's definitely worth reading. I won't look at Picasso's Guernica in the same way from now on. 10/10. 

    Sarita

    Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened.

    MySwaps
  • 02-01-2010 12:38 Post ID: 674,047  In reply to

    Re: Guernica by Dave Boling

    I found this magnificent, and I was very moved by both the family saga and the well documented events. I spent my gap year in a small town near Guernica, and was able to relate very well to the Basque characters described-and the landscape was also very evocative and realistic.

    I didn't see the final twist coming at all-and I was so glad! I felt it helped elevate it from the overwhelming anguish and despair which had been prevalent, and which gave some hope for the future.

    Like Sarita, I too will now view Picasso's work in a slightly different light.

    This was an astonishing debut novel, from an immensely talented author, who clearly knows, loves and respects his subject matter. 10/10.....and i don't often do that!


    Currently reading,"Dreams of Sex and Stage Diving", Martin Millar



Page 1 of 1 (12 items)