ReadItSwapIt
ReadItSwapIt Book Logo
ReadItSwapIt Forums Sign in | Forum FAQ

Shortcuts

We Need to Talk ABout Kevin **Spoiler**

Last post 10-19-2008 22:20 by cezzie. 26 replies.
Page 1 of 2 (27 items) 1 2 Next >
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  • 03-06-2008 8:41 Post ID: 301,394 

    We Need to Talk ABout Kevin **Spoiler**

    I started reading this this morning on the train and managed to get about 3 chapters in. So far, I've sussed out the bones of the story - it's written in the form of letters from this woman to her estranged husband and presumably they separated after their son went on a shooting spree a la Columbine, and the woman is still trying to deal with the aftermath. I'm not sure if I'm going to be able to stick with it though. The writing is very...erm...stylised, and I find myself thinking that Lionel Shriver has tried too hard here, it's almost as if she's showing off and saying "Oh look how lovely I can write". And in a funny kind of way, the style is making me feel less sympathetic for this woman, even though she has been through terrible trauma. Am I making any sense at all here? Anyway, I'm not sure if I'll stick with this one. What did you think? Does it get better as it goes along? What did you think of the style of writing? Is it worth persevering with?
  • 03-06-2008 8:43 Post ID: 301,397  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin

    Stick with it Tony it's worth it in the end........
    Currently reading Sleep Pale Sister by Joanne Harris and for book group this month Three Men In a Boat
  • 03-06-2008 9:01 Post ID: 301,412  In reply to

    • annecater
    • Top 10 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-04-2007
    • Land of Red Arrows & Sausages
    • Posts 14,136

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin

     Tony, I think this is one of the most debated books around, it's definitely a Marmite - love it or hate it.  I hated it, just couldnt bear the style of writing at all and gave up, probably around the place you are now!









  • 03-06-2008 9:11 Post ID: 301,428  In reply to

    • jobar
    • Top 25 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-04-2007
    • In the land of pies and piers....
    • Posts 7,588
    • Moderator

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin

    I hated it too.....!


  • 03-06-2008 9:13 Post ID: 301,430  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin

    I loved it......tried to quote anne it is not working.....
    Currently reading Sleep Pale Sister by Joanne Harris and for book group this month Three Men In a Boat
  • 03-06-2008 9:19 Post ID: 301,435  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin

    I really enjoyed it Tony! As Anne says it is either a love it or hate it book. I really enjoyed the writing and the story and found myself looking forward to reading it when I went to bed at night. It is one of my favourite books!





  • 03-06-2008 9:43 Post ID: 301,483  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin

    Have to agree with Shona, it was my fav book of 2006. I got used to her style at about page 50 or so, and really enjoyed it after that.
    The end is most definately worth it, very surprising and shocking! Well worth reading the book for. It's not a book I could ever forget.

    I know what you mean about not finding the mother very likeable, I've read 3 Shriver books now, and don't think I've liked a main character in any of them.
    She seems to specialise in non-maternal unsympathetic women characters. But I've always enjoyed the book. And Kevin is her best in my opinion.

    Currently reading: The Book of Air and Shadows by Michael Gruber
  • 03-06-2008 10:08 Post ID: 301,510  In reply to

    • kendie
    • Top 25 Contributor
    • Joined on 05-04-2007
    • Staffordshire
    • Posts 4,346

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin

    I thought it was a gread read - and yes one of those books you never forget. Stick with it Tony.

     

    Kendie is a Prolific Poster

  • 03-06-2008 10:16 Post ID: 301,515  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin **Spoiler**

    I really didn't like the book, so I gave up on it. I just did not like her way of writing.

    Currently reading: Four Blind Mice by James Patterson
  • 03-06-2008 12:00 Post ID: 301,613  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin **Spoiler**

    I'm so disappointed by this book, i had been dying to read it for ages.I think i don't like her writing style. I got to page 100 and gave up but i might give it another shot then put it on my swaps. Glad it's just me that didn't like this! x

    I have comrades in Heaven and allies in Hell

    Currently reading - Elizabeth by David Starkey

    My Swaps

    My Wishlist

    My TBR
  • 03-06-2008 12:20 Post ID: 301,631  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin **Spoiler**

    This is on my TBR, I will get round to it eventually, is nice to see the mixed opinions of it before I read it

    Currently Reading - Twilight by Stephenie Meyer
    Amount of books read in January: 5
    Books read in 2008: 244
  • 03-06-2008 19:48 Post ID: 302,021  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin **Spoiler**

    Another vote for 'stick with it'.  Like Liz, once I got used to the style I was gripped by the storyline and couldn't wait to find out what terrible things Kevin would do next. 

    I don't think we're meant to sympathise with Eva - I think one of the questions the books asks is whether she got the son she deserved!

    Currently Reading: ~The Guernsey Literary & Potato Peel Society
    Swaps
    TBR
    Wishlist
  • 03-07-2008 10:38 Post ID: 302,306  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin **Spoiler**

    Sorry folks but I've given up on this. I tried to get into it, I really did but a number of things totally put me off. 1. The writing style is incredibly verbose and long-winded. Shriver doesn't use one word where twelve will do. 2. The conceit of having the main character Eva writing the letters was irritating too and kept dragging me out of the book. She spends absoluely AGES in these letters describing events to her estranged husband and I kept thinking "Why is she doing this? He was THERE during these events!!" It just struck me as an incredibly contrived and artificial way of telling a story. 3. For the life of me, I couldn't find an iota of sympathy for Eva. She's pompous, self-centred, cold and egotistical. 4. It's perfectly clear that Shriver has never had children, nor has she researched children for this book. No parent would let their child's obvious developmental faults and behavioural problems go unchecked for so long. Sorry to be so negative, I really wanted to like this but I couldn't.
  • 03-07-2008 20:56 Post ID: 302,776  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin **Spoiler**

    Telboy9999:
    Sorry folks but I've given up on this. I tried to get into it, I really did but a number of things totally put me off. 1. The writing style is incredibly verbose and long-winded. Shriver doesn't use one word where twelve will do. 2. The conceit of having the main character Eva writing the letters was irritating too and kept dragging me out of the book. She spends absoluely AGES in these letters describing events to her estranged husband and I kept thinking "Why is she doing this? He was THERE during these events!!" It just struck me as an incredibly contrived and artificial way of telling a story. 3. For the life of me, I couldn't find an iota of sympathy for Eva. She's pompous, self-centred, cold and egotistical. 4. It's perfectly clear that Shriver has never had children, nor has she researched children for this book. No parent would let their child's obvious developmental faults and behavioural problems go unchecked for so long. Sorry to be so negative, I really wanted to like this but I couldn't.

    "Shriver doesn't use one word where twelve will do"  Can't argue with you there Tony!  I didn't notice it so much with Kevin but I certainly did in The Post Birthday World.

    You'd have got the answer to your second question if you'd made it to the end, but if you weren't enjoying it then I don't blame you for giving up. 

    Currently Reading: ~The Guernsey Literary & Potato Peel Society
    Swaps
    TBR
    Wishlist
  • 03-07-2008 21:15 Post ID: 302,803  In reply to

    Re: We Need to Talk ABout Kevin **Spoiler**

    Sorry you were unable to get into this one, Tony, it's one of my favourite books in 2006.  The style is long-winded and very verbose (reminds me of myself!!) but it did improve but I know a lot of folk gave up on it. It does raise a lot of important questions about why people want to be parents, whether maternal feelings are guaranteed and would agree with Denise that you have to read to the end to make sense of the whole structure.  Perhaps another time, or then again maybe not??





Page 1 of 2 (27 items) 1 2 Next >