must be the only book i have ever cried at it realli made me think too about ivf and the reasons for it, but i still prefer nineteen minutes as my fave getting her new book from america next week am so excited

charnterelle:

Wasn't so much that I wanted a happy ending but I would have preferred the sister who was actually dying to have died in the end. Just thought it was stupid, all the way through ur gearing urself up for Kate to die and Anna to finally be allowed to have a life, and then she gets killed. Am still annoyed thinking about it lol

LOL! This is exactly how I felt.

I absolutely didn't want a happy ending. The ending of the book was stupid for me too. If it helps, I read the book back in July 2007, and I'm still annoyed.

makes it seem like all she went through was for nothin

smalley:

charnterelle:

Wasn't so much that I wanted a happy ending but I would have preferred the sister who was actually dying to have died in the end. Just thought it was stupid, all the way through ur gearing urself up for Kate to die and Anna to finally be allowed to have a life, and then she gets killed. Am still annoyed thinking about it lol

LOL! This is exactly how I felt.

I absolutely didn't want a happy ending. The ending of the book was stupid for me too. If it helps, I read the book back in July 2007, and I'm still annoyed.

Lol my mother in law borrowed it after I read it and I said "pfft you can have it?" and she said "what didnt you like it?" and i said to you that i couldnt tell her what i didnt like cos it would spoil it for her, but am still annoyed 3 days on lol I will prob still be annoyed about it in 6 months time as well lol

And in answer to kingsummers: That was my exact thoughts as well

Have just finished reading this, certainly didn't see the ending coming! - I had to go back and read that bit again just to make sure I'd read it correctly.

Really enjoyed reading it tho - shall continue to work my way through her other books